the numbers guy

Alberta Election Projection – Wildrose on track for solid majority

Posted on: April 22, 2012

Alberta’s hard-fought provincial election takes place tomorrow (Monday 23 April). It has shaped up as a head-to-head contest between the governing Progressive Conservatives (who have been in power for over 40 years) and the right wing conservative Wildrose Party. Wildrose surged into a strong early lead in the campaign, but some polls taken over recent days have hinted that the race may be tightening in the final stretch.

Alberta is the heartland of Canadian conservatism and, while the NDP and Liberals will be a factor in Edmonton and, to a lesser extent Calgary, neither is in the hunt for seats in rural Alberta. The small, centrist Alberta Party and the EverGreen Party are also contesting the election.

For last fall’s provincial elections in Prince Edward Island and Saskatchewan, this blog confined itself to setting the scene – looking at where the close contests might be and so on. For the Alberta election, I’m going to go a step further, and attempt to project the results, riding by riding, based on the most recent polling evidence available.

Constructing a reasonably accurate seat projection model for Alberta 2012 presented a number of challenges. A recent boundary reviewincreased the number of seats in the legislature from 83 to 87. There was a great deal of shuffling around of electoral boundaries, particularly in urban areas, which made a straight projection of districts from the 2008 results difficult. Where boundary changes were significant, I made a best estimation based on previous poll-by-poll results, as to how the 2008 election would have gone if contested on the new 87-district boundaries.

I also made a few further tweaks, reflecting the likely impact of high profile defections, such as that of Guy Boutilier from PC to Wildrose in Fort McMurray-Wood Buffalo. For seats where Wildrose didn’t stand a candidate in 2008, I assigned them a notional support value, reflecting that of their weakest 2008 electoral districts in that region. I didn’t assign an incumbency bonus for sitting MLAs – but I did give a bonus for the party leaders.

All this resulted in a set of baseline figures for each of the 87 electoral districts and, after some deliberation, I opted for a proportional swing model to project each result. I had some reluctance in doing so, as a weakness of this kind of model can be in an election which sees a party surge from almost nowhere at the previous election. This was the case with the NDP in Quebec in last year’s federal election, and it looks like being the case with Wildrose in this election – who are leading in the polls at around 40% despite polling just 6.8% at the previous election (and who didn’t even contest over a quarter of the seats in 2008).

Nevertheless, a proportional model is far superior to alternatives such as uniform swing – so we’ll see how it fares when the results are in. We’re likely to face a similar ‘surge from almost nowhere’ situation in British Columbia next year with the rise of the BC Conservatives and, if necessary, I’ll make adjustments to my BC model to reflect this.

The best seat prediction model in the world will fail if the input information (the polling evidence) is inaccurate. The numbers I fed into the model came from aggregating the results of the final surveys of pollsters who have been regularly polling the race. These numbers were broken down into three regions – Calgary, Edmonton and the Rest of Alberta – with a view to capturing localized trends, such as the apparent steep decline in Liberal support in the Calgary region.

The results are at the top of this thread – a solid majority for Wildrose who are projected to win 55 seats across the province. The Progressive Conservatives are projected to be reduced to just 27 seats – a huge drop from the 72 they won at the 2008 election. The Liberals are narrowly projected to pick up a single seat in a very tight four-way race in Edmonton Centre. The NDP are projected to win 4 seats – by picking up two extra seats in Edmonton.

  • Regionally the model projects Calgary to return 22 Wildrose and 5 PCs.
  • In Edmonton, it projects 13 PCs, 11 Wildrose, 4 NDP and 1 Liberal.
  • In the rest of Alberta, Wildrose is projected to win 22 seats, with the PCs winning 9.

I’m looking forward to seeing how these figures – and my headline total of Wildrose 55, PC 27, NDP 4, Lib 1 – compares with reality when the results come through on Monday night.

3 Responses to "Alberta Election Projection – Wildrose on track for solid majority"

David, interesting read. I for one will keep an eye on your model vs reality Tuesday morning.

Thanks Rudy. Turns out my model (based on the polling figures) was out by a country mile – I’ve just posted an initial post-mortem looking at why…

[…] About Alberta Election Projection – Wildrose on track for solid majority […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

  • None

Twitter – numbersguyblog

%d bloggers like this: